Well, I had no intention of watching the finals show.
In fact, with "Lost" winding up its season with a
2-hour finale at the same time plus a catch-you-up
show at 8:00, my plan was to just stick with the one
and ignore the other because I did not want to see 2
hours of crap-filled filler just to have Taylor
announced as the winner.
Imagine my surprise, then, when I switched over from
"Lost" during a commercial at 8:14 pm and saw Paris
singing a duet with Al Jareau. What? Al Jareau is
here? Then, Ryan introduced Chris - and he was
singing with Live! Man, oh, man, that was good -
what's going on here?
It appears that I missed the first song of the night,
which was current AI, Carrie Underwood, singing with
Kat and Taylor. I imagine I didn't miss much.
Then, for a little humor, we had Wolfgang Puck and
Kellie Pickler in a little thing called "Puck and
Pickler". Which basically played on the fact the
Kellie is pretty ignorant about exotic food, as am I,
and can't always pronounce it or believe that people
actually eat it (again, ME). So, when Puck introduced
her to escargot from the menu, she couldn't believe
people actually ate snails, and then a plate of them
appeared in front of her and she was shocked to be
told to eat one. Which she pretended to do but was
grossed out and spit it into her napkin and placed it
under her chair (hah! me exactly). They followed
later in the show with another little vignette about
lobster, which she knew about and might have even
eaten, but they placed two live, crawling-around
lobsters on the table and she freaked (again, ME).
Her food reactions are so in tune with me and mine
that I have a great time watching and understanding
her where other folks might not. When it comes to
food and what you will and will not put in your mouth,
Kellie and I are cosmic sisters.
Anyway, on to the music. Following Pickler and Puck,
Meatloaf came onstage and sang with Kat. Now, I'm a Meatloaf
fan from way back and even I thought something was off about the
performance - I think it started in the wrong key for him and then he
added bunches of vibrato which I didn't like - but it was great seeing him. The song
just didn't work for them. I heard later he was upset about the performance.
Ryan then introduced a new stupid part of the show - the
Golden Idols. He said they would award a few that
night, and started with Outstanding Female Vocalist.
These were culled from the best of the worst of the
auditions. They showed a few of the "nominations" and
then awarded it to Princess Brewer, who thought she
sounded like Aretha Franklin and auditioned with
"That's What Friends Are For." And sucked the big one.
Ryan then moved on to Outstanding Male Vocal. There
was no shortage of worthwhile auditions (snark.) but
nobody could forget Crazy Dave Hoover jumping around
and singing "Bat Out of Hell." Crazy Dave was there
and leapt around the stage to accept his award. yawn.
The male finalists, all wearing black, sang a montage
of "guy songs." "Taking Care of Business", "Tobacco
Road", "Don't Stop" - Bucky! was as sweet and
beautiful as ever - Kevin and Ace were just there,
Elliot looked and sounded great, Taylor even sang well
- when these guys sing together they really do sound
better than any of the previous seasons' group
sing-along mixes. Chris was awesome also. I was
thrilled to see Bucky! who, you know if you've been
reading this, is my favorite. Not so much for his
singing which is good in a honky-tonk-bar kind of way
but he is so sweet, he has such a lovely smile and he
seems so genuine that something about him just tugs at
me and makes me smile when I see him. (sorry, I can't
help it. It's out of my control.)
Next, they showed a new Ford Pimpommercial, one that
combined parts of all the previous ones, and featured
Kat and Taylor sitting in a drive-in theater in a
convertible, watching the season's pimpommercials.
When they returned to the stage, Ryan had Kat and
Taylor up there with him and he surprised them both
with keys to a brand new Mustang convertible. yawn.
Golden Idol: Proudest Family Moment.
This was a pretty nice one, because it showcased
three nice things: Elliott's mom who has always been there for him and
whom we've kind of gotten to know over the past
several weeks; Chris' wife, who has been so supportive
of him; and Kat's dad, who loves his little girl so
much and has cried gallons of tears on national TV.
And the winner is, Elliott's mom.
Ryan asks E-Mom to introduce her baby, Elliott, which
she does, and Elliott comes on stage to sing "One." A
few bars into the song Mary J. Blige slides on stage
to join him and it's awesome, except she kind of hogs
the song but I don't think he cares - it's nice to see
Elliott so Happy - he's just beaming. She was kind of rude to him.
Cut to Lost: the end of Reckoning - me to the TV as
Michael is thrown out of the bushes to Jack and Kate:
"Don't trust Michael! Leave him in the jungle!
Aacchhh!!!"
Carrie is next, and she's fresh from her wins the
night before at the Country Music Awards: Best New
Female Vocalist, and Best Song (Jesus Take The Wheel).
She's absolutely gorgeous and sings her new single,
"Don't Forget to Remember Me." It's pretty good, but
all I can think of is how bored Simon must be - he
hates country music (or at least that's his story).
At the same time, he must be very proud of Carrie and
her accomplishments - in only one year.
Golden Idol Award: The Randy Jackson Award for Public
Speaking.
This was won hands down by Rhonetta Johnson, who
appeared to us in auditions in a white miniskirt,
silver tube top, silver go-go boots, and possessing
the biggest potty-mouth in the history of history.
They presented her award to "her"* via satellite, made
some jokes, she got mouthy and they "lost the
satellite feed." She was unnecessary. She's very
crude and AI is giving her 15 minutes of undeserved
fame. *I think it was a look-alike but it was hard to tell.
Back to music: Taylor comes out and starts singing
"In The Ghetto." A few bars in, he's joined onstage
by Toni Braxton and they sing it out together. This
combination worked less well than some of the others,
but it was OK.
Next, the Girls do their medley of "girl" songs: "Man,
I feel Like a Woman", "I Am Woman", "Natural Woman",
"I've Every Woman" - it was all pretty good. This was
Lisa, Melissa (who?), Kat, Kellie, Mandisa and Paris.
This was really good, they all sounded great,
especially Mandisa who is awesome, but still needs someone to dress her.
Golden Idol: Best Impersonation of Another Artist
This one was pretty funny: It featured Kenneth ? when
he auditioned in Cher's voice - or what he thought was
Cher's voice. Hysterically funny the second time too.
Seth Strickland, who thought he was a dead-ringer
white-boy for Michael Jackson during the Thriller-era,
but who couldn't remember the words, couldn't sing and
dance at the same time, and kept saying "Oh, Crap"
when he couldn't remember where he was in the song.
You just can't make up this stuff.
The next nominee was Michael, who had fixed his hair
and dress to resemble Clay Aiken, and was proud of the
fact that he "sounded" like Clay too, except he
didn't. At all. Poor Michael was severely deluded,
but he sure liked Clay. Oh, I almost forgot - he's
the one who, when he realized how badly he was doing,
told the judges "I'm nervous as hell and I gotta go
pee." HAH! So they let him go pee, to the
accompanyment of the Chariots of Fire Theme, and he tried again
and was just as bad.
And the winner was, of course, Michael aka "Clay". He
came onstage to receive his "award" and Ryan asked him
if he would like to sing one of Clay's songs - "Don't
Let the Sun Go Down on Me", and he was excited and
started right in. The kid seriously thinks he can
sing, I think, and he closed his eyes and started
crooning - they let him get just a couple of bars in
when the curtain opened behind him and a newly-coiffed
(longer, dark hair) Clay Aiken stepped out and started
singing with him. The audience went crazy, Michael
opened his eyes wondering what was going on, took a
few seconds before he realized the attention was no
longer on him, turned around, saw Clay, and screamed
and yelled and jumped around. He was almost beside
himself with excitement. It was very genuine and so
touching that, even though that whole maneuver is so
hackneyed and old, it was awesome and made me a bit
teary-eyed. Michael just kept singing (sort of - he was
shaking very badly) with Clay, until Ryan finally
brought him a stool to sit on before he fell over, and
Clay pretty much took over the song, but Michael's
face was just awesome to watch - the tears were
rolling, he was shaking and awestruck and the look in
his eyes was just magical. In fact, it was Michael,
not Clay, who made that moment shine. It was Magic of
a kind we're not privileged to see very often. Some people
thought it was hokey - I think it was sweet and rawly emotional.
Bert Bacharach was next - he and the Finalists sang a
(long) montage of a bunch of his songs, but then
Dionne Warwick came out and sang with them. The
Bert/Dionne relationship goes way, way back and it was
fun watching them interact again. This was
quite a long segment but it was pretty good. She sang
"Walk on By" and with the group sang "That's What
Friends Are For." I've never been a big Dionne fan so this was just OK for me.
Plus, there was a real clunker note at the end from Dionne.
Lost: What's with the statue? Huh? It's only a leg
from mid-calf on down and there are only 4 toes. It's
on the beach - Sayid, Jin and Sun see it from the
boat. Oh, man, this is definitely something we won't
see again until next year.
Golden Idol: Male Bonding
A reprise of the 3 cowboys from the auditions (Garrett
and the other two I don't know). They came out, AI
called them the Brokenote Cowboys (ha ha.) and they
sang "Mamas Don't Let Your Babies Grow Up To Be
Cowboys." It was actually pretty good and kind of
cool to see them because they were all (especially
little Garrett) a big part of the auditions.
(The way the rest of the night had gone, I was kind of
hoping Willie Nelson would pop out from behind the
curtain while they were singing, but he didn't).
Ryan's back on stage, and he says "OK, down to
business - no more guest stars. Let's hear it for
your finalists!." Audience starts whooping, the lights
start flashing, the music rises, camera points to the
closed curtain and........two scantily clad dancing
girls come out. What? They gyrate for a few seconds
- point to the curtain (ala The Price Is Right) and
out comes...........Prince. The crowd explodes and he
sings two songs - "Satisfied" and another. That Ryan
is such a trickster.
OK, down to business again, really, this time. Ryan
calls out Kat and Taylor. 63 MILLION votes Tuesday
night ("more votes than a Presidential election" or something),
Taylor wins. Who cares.
Kat is gracious and lovely, Taylor is overwhelmed and
when he gets himself back together he sings his new single, the
title of which I forgot already but it's the one he
sang Tuesday night, the typical AI ballad.
I never wanted Taylor to win. But from the first of
the final 12 and I saw how he never finished in the
bottom 3 or the bottom 2 and his popularity grew, I
knew he would win. I resigned myself to it when Chris
was voted off, then Elliot was voted off.
Taylor annoys the crap out of me with his spazzy
moves, his fetal-back dancing, and his various tics,
but the fact is that he comes across as always being
upbeat and pretty joyful just to be there. And he
loves to sing. I think he's basically an ass, but
America voted him as their next American Idol, so now
they have him. Enjoy!